Oregon alum George Wrighster claps back on Indiana fans sure of a repeat

Six-year NFL vet and former Oregon tight end George Wrighster has a message for Indiana fans who think repeating as NCAA champions will come easy for Curt Cignetti.

"ESPN has Indiana over Oregon for the best off season ranking in the Big Ten," Wrightster said recently on his college football podcast. "This could not have been more outrageous."

"Indiana and their fans, the way they've acted after winning a national championship. Yes, they should be excited. But their excitement for this season is delusion."

Wrighster thinks Hoosier fans have forgotten their history, and how difficult it is to repeat as champions. "They have no idea how college football works on this level."

While he acknowledges Cignetti's accomplishment in taking a downtrodden program and turning it around in two seasons with an historic 16-0 run, repeating as champions is an even more difficult one.

Just last year Ohio State had the best player in college football in Jeremiah Smith, the game's most accurate quarterback and four players taken in the first ten picks of the NFL draft (three on defense) and they couldn't do it.

Though Cignetti is a film savant and a great evaluator of talent, it's unrealistic to believe that the 64-year-old coach can just plug and play Josh Hoover at quarterback seamlessly.

"You can't guarantee production replacement over a Heisman winner, multiple high NFL draft picks." Wrighster said.

Wide receivers Omar Cooper and Elijah Surratt will be hard to replace. Cornerback D'Angelo Ponds was an All-American. It took a toe-tap reception by Cooper against Penn State to preserve that undefeated season, a long pass late in the fourth quarter to Surratt against Iowa.

The 2025 Hoosiers made every big play they needed.

Though Cignetti remains a great coach with two strong coordinators, a national championship run is a magical experience, one that takes toughness, sacrifice and injury luck. The organization is first-rate in every detail. Results may not be.

Pressure firmly on Hoover, outsized expectations

A lot hinges on Hoover, the transfer quarterback from TCU. He threw 33 interceptions in three seasons with the Horned Frogs, sacked 18 times last year. In two of those seasons, his interception rate was three percent.

Mendoza threw six interceptions last season at IU, but that was the same rate he produced at Cal the year before, 1.6 percent, nearly half of Hoover's. "It shows that Indiana didn't make Mendoza," Wrighster said. "They just gave him more opportunities to succeed."

Hoover doesn't have Mendoza's mobility and escapability, either. The Heisman winner is 6-5, 225. He ran for 276 yards and 7 touchdowns operating the IU offense. At TCU, Hoover ran for -10 yards over 122 carries in his three years as a starter. He's 6-2, 200, far from a Mendoza clone. Although he may be effective with a sound running game and a good defense, he's not the same guy.

Neither are Nick Marsh and Turbo Richardson duplicates of the players they're replacing in the Indiana system.

FanDuel sets the Hoosiers' national championship odds at +750 with the over/under win total at 10.5. They're contenders. National Coach of the Year last season, Cignetti will certainly get the best from them.

"If Nick Saban at Alabama couldn't win a title every year, neither can Curt Cignetti," Wrighster said.

In the BCS/College Football Playoff era just two teams have repeated as national champions, Alabama in 2011 and 2012, Georgia in 2021 and 2022. Neither of those squads had to win a 12-team playoff.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow